Summer – Winter – Summer

Last week, when I said that this knitted sweater would be next on the blog, it felt a little bit weird – and kind of wrong – because the weekend had been particularly hot, and I’d got tan lines on my thighs from our cycle ride. Summer was here, it seemed. So it felt like a hugely weather disappropriate choice of garment to put up next. But you know what? It doesn’t seem so weird now, because in true British style it’s been bloody freezing this week. I’ve been layering up in the house with T-shirts, sweaters and my dressing gown. It’s that cold. I just don’t know what is up with the weather right now 🤷🏻‍♀️

giphy 124

But at least – slowly, surely – summer is approaching, even if there are still days that I’m snuggled up in my fleecy hooded blanket like it’s mid-December 🥶 Speaking of that blanket, it’s one of MANY things that I need to photograph for the blog – which I’m thinking I can now do given the British government have said we can go outside as much as we like 🤔 The only spanner in the works is that I can’t get public transport to my usual East London photo spot… so it’s looking like the husbeast is gonna be braving the central London roads in the car to get me there 👀 😂 Plus, I need to get that blanket photographed pronto because it’s a proper heat-fest to wear and if it’s warm outside, I may just die after about 30 seconds of wearing it.


But anyway… back to my weather inappropriate/appropriate (delete as applicable according to the weather where you are) knitted sweater.

I know I’m like way late to the party with this one, but I’ve got another one of my 2019 Make Nine ticked off with this bad boy 😂 Better late than never…

This Malabrigo Caracol yarn stole my heart when we visited Philadelphia in 2018, from a little store called Yarnphoria. The lady who ran the store was so nice, so helpful, and she even had a little doggo in there too! Yarn shop + doggo = best possible combo. The Caracol yarn reminded me of a stained glass window, with the black thread running through it. I bought some of the Diana colourway for me, and the Cameleon colourway for the husbeast. When we were in NYC a few months back (y’know, when travel was still a thing) the husbeast bought himself another colourway of this same yarn… so I now have two more sweaters to knit before the weather turns chilly again!

3ddc586c 3c51 4cbc 9ef9 5d95099391e6

Pattern-wise for my yarn, I knew that I wanted a simple, stocking stitch sweater with a roll neck. Something slightly oversized, that would keep me cosy when the weather got chilly. Even though a plain stocking stitch sweater isn’t the most exciting of things to handknit, I felt that it best allowed the colours and thick-thin texture of the yarn to shine. I’m all about the cables and extras (usually), but they would have just got lost among the busyness of the yarn here. So for this project, vanilla was the way forward. I never thought I’d say that.

As I always do, I delved into Ravelry to see what patterns they had that fitted my criteria. There were several options, but in the end, I settled on a free pattern (woohoo for freebies!) from Rowan – a Vogue Knitting Live Sweater and Snood combo.

VKL Sweater medium2

Obvs I wasn’t going to include that intarsia ‘VK’ logo, and the separate snood wasn’t going to be made either – instead, I was just going to add on a ribbed tube for a neck, long enough to be folded over double. The rolled hem also wasn’t my thing – but it seemed to appear on the majority of patterns I looked at for whatever reason 🤷🏻‍♀️ – so the plan was to start with an inch or so of ribbing on the hem and sleeves.

The hanks of this Caracol yarn are hand-dyed, and as such, they have no dye lot. This was my first experience of using hand-dyed yarn, and I didn’t realise at the time I bought it that: (a) it was hand-dyed, or (b) the colours in each hank could vary considerably because of this. I just bought eight random hanks – I know now that I should have instead looked at all the hanks they had and picked ones that had a similar colour balance… but hey. I know now, and that’s the main thing!

Thankfully, most of the hanks were largely similar, with a mix of yellow, pink, purple, and green. Some hanks had spatterings of vibrant reds, greens, and blues. A couple of hanks didn’t have any green or blue, and instead were a mash of the warmer colours – red, purple, pink and orange. I set these ones aside for the sleeves and used the rest of the similar-ish hanks on the body.

img 6231

img 6244

I actually did a little swatch for this sweater (because I’d completely gone off track from their recommended yarn) and found my gauge was slightly off – the recommended tension was 10 stitches and 12 rows, and I had the right number of stitches, but 10 rows instead of 12 to 4 inches. I had sized down from the recommended 10mm needle size to 9mm to get the number of stitches correct, but this didn’t seem to help the row situation. Maybe I should have stuck with the 10mm 🤷🏻‍♀️ It’s close enough, so whatever. I don’t think the final sweater was impacted in any way.

I wasn’t really sure how to approach the differences in colour in the skeins – I started doing some online research, and there were a few suggestions for working with hand-dyed yarns:

  • Alternate a couple of hanks, changing every round
  • Alternate three hanks in the same manner, if they are all pretty different
  • Don’t do anything, just roll with whatever happens

The last option seemed the most appealing (and the least effort), but then I started seeing horror stories of projects where people had taken this approach:

DSCN1643 640x480 1

Eesh. I did NOT want that happening to me.

giphy 121

So, I went with alternating a couple of skeins, to avoid ending up with something that looked like the picture above.

This proved to not be the right approach, however – the colours ended up looking stripy. I got a large patch of light colours striping with dark colours, and I didn’t like the way the colours of each row looked next to each other. My gorgeous looking hanks were producing fabric that looked like colour vomit. Eeeesh. NOT what I wanted. In one place, some bright red and green ended up next to each other on a series of rows, making it look like a Christmas jumper. Nope. No way. I wasn’t having my beautiful (and expensive) yarn turned into some hideous sweater. I ripped back, licked my wounds and reconsidered my options.

img 6236
Not digging the colour vomit going on here

I put out a cry for help and advice on the ‘gram, to which lots of you lovely folk offered pretty much consistent advice: don’t bother alternating skeins, and instead start the new hank on the same part of the rainbow as where the last one finished, to avoid obvious changes. This was something I hadn’t thought of, and is the approach I went with.

And you guys… IT WORKED.

giphy 125

The rainbow wasn’t always exactly the same on each hank – some colours had longer bits compared to others, or were not there at all – but I matched it as best I could. It wasn’t until I got right to the top of the back, where the main body narrows, that I ended up with a larger-than-I-liked patch of green, and although you can loosely see where the colour shifts from the different hanks it’s pretty damn hard to pinpoint the exact spot that the changeover took place 👀

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8589

Before ripping back because of the colour-vomit issue, I had started out with a size medium at the hips, reducing to a size small in the body – but when I had made some progress I realised that actually, it was WAY too big. On the second attempt, I decided that I’d make the XS. I was making the decision totally blind, though, because helpfully there were no measurements – body OR finished ones – on the pattern. Anywhere. I mean, WTF? I know it was a free pattern and all, but come on guys. Sizing is like the one job you have as a pattern designer, and you’ve sacked it off.

giphy 122


When I started again, I ended up with this lovely pooled rainbow on the bottom rib, which sadly didn’t transfer to the main body of the jumper ☹️ I always think it’s a bit of a gamble buying yarns like this – I’m never sure how they will turn out as knitted fabric, and it hardly ever seems to correspond to how they look in their wound hanks 🤷🏻‍♀️

img 6241

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8624

The body of the sweater knitted up pretty quickly, given how big it is – though that’s mainly due to the chunkiness of the yarn and the thick needles. I knitted the first ten rows in 2 x 2 rib rather than the rolled edge instructed in the pattern.

After steaming through the front and back, completing the sleeves (again with an inch of rib at the cuff) and declaring myself on the home straight with just the roll neck and the seaming to go, I realised that one sleeve was WAY different to the other, and also quite different to the main body of the sweater. It became apparent that I had one skein which had a LOT of dark blues, purples and red – a colour that didn’t really appear in any of the other skeins. Hmm.

img 7266

img 7262

giphy 123

It didn’t look good. I examined what I had leftover of the other skeins, to see if I could construct a matching sleeve from them… and I reckoned I could. I had to dip back into that one rogue red skein for the very top part of the sleeve, but you can see the main bodies of the sleeves are now vaguely similar 🙌🏻 That leftover skein still sits in my yarn stash… I’m thinking it might become a hat one day.

img 7437

With all the pieces now complete (after I don’t know how many rip backs and restarts 😑) I picked up the stitches around the neckline for my roll neck. I worked in a 2 x 2 rib for as long as I thought I needed (I wanted the neck to fold down on itself in a double layer) and cast off. I realise now that I should have done a super-stretchy cast-off, because the edge doesn’t have that much give in it. Not enough give to match the circumference of where I cast on for the neck, so it doesn’t quite fold down perfectly, but it’ll do.

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8609

You’re instructed to work all pieces flat for this sweater – but I’m firmly a member of the in-the-round fan club so I cast on for the body as one piece, divided front and back when I got to the armpits and worked the remainder of each separately. I did the same with the sleeves – cast on in the round and just continued up to the same point before working the rows back and forth for the shoulder. I already had loads of ends to weave in from where I’d chopped and changed hanks, so I didn’t want to have to spend hours seaming the thing up as well 😩 If I could be really fussy about the whole thing, I’d have rather knitted the whole thing top-down without any shoulder seaming – pieced knitting is not my favourite construction anyway, but in this yarn it’s particularly bulky, especially around the armscye.


I’m happy with the finished sweater though, and it’s reflective of what I had in my mind when I started out. I don’t know how this jumper is going to cope with washing… it’s heavy enough dry, let alone when it’s soaked with water. I have visions of it stretching out of shape when wet 😱 With just a couple of wears is it starting to show signs of pilling and fuzz, which I guess is what you get with soft yarns like this… and oh my days thread, dog hair and all other small floaty things stick to it like a bastard.

It is, however, super snuggly, so all is forgiven 🥰

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8596

I’ve already chosen the pattern for the husbeast’s yarn, so I’ll be cracking on with that next – but it might be a bit of a sweaty choice for a summer project 🤔 My yarn stash is nowhere NEAR the volume of my fabric stash, but I’d like to try and use it up – some of the contents I’ve had for an embarrassing amount of years and it’s high time I either did something with it or passed it on to someone that will use it. Thankfully, my tastes in yarn don’t appear to have changed, and I still like everything I have, so there’s no excuse really. It certainly isn’t fulfilling its life goals by sitting in a plastic tub under the bed in our spare room, that’s for sure, so I’m hoping to enable it to become something over the next year or so. I have no idea what to do with all my leftover yarn from previous projects though – there isn’t enough for a garment, so… what? A crochet blanket that consumes leftovers as they come? Donate them to someone? Hit me up with your suggestions!

Hope you’re all keeping safe and lockdown isn’t driving you crazy 💜

Until next week ✌🏻

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8542

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8584

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8602

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8578

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8588

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8618

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8593

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8614

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8601

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8607

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8620

Malabrigo Caracol Rowan VK Live 8573

Next week on the blog – not something I can really use right now, but we made a money belt to take to craft fairs we hold stalls at! 🛍 Subscribe below to have the post drop straight into your inbox 🙌🏻


Enter your email address below to receive fabulous new posts direct to your inbox! No spam ever, just handmade awesomeness for you to enjoy.



  1. artcoopsville
    May 17, 2020 / 8:23 am

    I love it. Beautiful colours, so wish I could knit.

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 3:58 pm

      Thank you! 💜 You should definitely give it a try! I started out with a simple scarf, to learn the stitches and the method. After that you can progress to bigger and better things, the sky is the limit! 💪🏻 I’m sure there are lots of YouTube videos out there which could start you off 🙂

  2. Helen Jackson
    May 17, 2020 / 8:45 am

    Well done you I would have given up long ago, isn’t it annoying when you’ve spent all this time knitting a beautiful jumper and it starts to pill and wear so quickly

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 3:59 pm

      Thanks Helen! Yeah… there’s that fine line between a hard-wearing (and slighly less soft) yarn, or an absolutely dreamy-squishy yarn that pills 🤷🏻‍♀️ I guess you can’t have it both ways!

  3. Bren Holmes
    May 17, 2020 / 10:48 am

    Your sweater looks proper cosy and full marks for perseverance. Yarn leftovers are a problem. I donated a lot of mine to a local college for the textiles students. Most of my ‘yarn’ stash is in the form of rovings for wet felting. I used to do a lot of wet felting, but haven’t done any for a few years now, yet I have at least four large tubs of it stored away. It’s so soft, pretty and colourful 🙂
    My fabric stash is getting used, since I can’t get out to buy any fabric at present. That’s something, at least. I’ve been investing in quilting accessories by clicking ‘add to basket’ quite frequently. Quilting is going to be the order of the day for a while, me thinks. I’ve been sewing for the NHS for the past few weeks, but will complete that today and will get back to my waiting projects.

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:07 pm

      Thanks Bren! 💜 I’m glad I got there in the end!
      Oooh I bet those tubs are a wonder to look at 🤩 My cat would be in one of them like a shot for a nap 😂
      There’s not a lot of sewing going on for me… so my fabric stash is mostly just sitting there! But, I’ve been good and not bought anything either. I have instead been formulating plans for some of the stash pieces, and choosing patterns to use up my yarn stash. Despite me not getting round to it yet, I’m still proper excited to start my quilt kit!! How are your projects coming along now you’re getting back to them?

  4. Zak
    May 17, 2020 / 10:53 am

    You’re a more patient person than me to rip out and redo that much work! Looks to have been worth it though.

    I think Christmas is a good time for all the leftovers from old projects. Gloves, hats, mittens, socks are great presents if you have half a skein here and there, and even a few random lonesome feet of a colour make funky accent stripes for a few rows to use them up. That’s my solution!

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:14 pm

      Haha, I’m not sure I have patience… ‘determination’ might be the better word 😂
      Ooh yes that’s a good idea – gifts! I thought the odds and ends were all destined to become *another* blanket for the dog but perhaps not! Thanks! 💜

  5. Kim H
    May 17, 2020 / 5:20 pm

    What a journey and to a beautiful end. Wear it proudly! I love the colors 🎨

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:14 pm

      Thanks Kim! Such beautiful colours aren’t they 😍

  6. Pence
    May 17, 2020 / 6:23 pm

    Have you ever thought about doing the sleeves like they do with Icelandic style sweaters – also knitted in the round. you knit in the round down each sleeve after ‘casting on’ by picking up the yarn through the edge stitches at the bottom of the armhole openings, knitting the sleeves, and picking up the entire mass to knit (reducing madly) for the top of the yolk to the neck.
    A convoluted description, but back when I did my first Icelandic the directions were easy to follow.
    And that was the first sweater I had ever knitted!

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:18 pm

      The sweater I’m knitting now sounds kind of similar, but backwards – you cast on at the neck opening, increasing for the yoke and shoulders, then the sleeve stitches get put to one side while you carry on with the body down to the hem. Then, you go back and pick up those sleeve stitches (plus cast on a few at the armpit) and carry on in the round down to the cuff. Is that similar? Do the Icelandic sweaters get knit from the hem up to the neck?

  7. Maggie Muggleton
    May 17, 2020 / 6:30 pm

    Love it! X

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:18 pm

      Thank you Maggie! 💜

  8. May 18, 2020 / 1:34 am

    This absolute gorgeousness!!!! I am impressed with the effort you went to in order for the colours to turn out so well.

    • Sarah
      May 23, 2020 / 4:27 pm

      Ahh thanks Valerie! It’s so snuggly and warm to wear! 😍

  9. Ruth Lister
    May 18, 2020 / 12:06 pm

    That yarn is amazing, as is the finished jumper.

  10. Lodi
    May 19, 2020 / 11:52 am

    Love your sweater – just beautiful!

  11. May 21, 2020 / 6:41 am

    Wow, what a labour of love! Well done! 👏🏻👏🏻

  12. Bren Holmes
    May 23, 2020 / 8:43 pm

    My wool is all stored in Really Useful boxes, with tight fitting lids. My cats cannot get into them, or they would be hunkered down in them, for sure!
    As for projects, I have a new UFO, due to an online class yesterday, the other UFOs are still UFOs, I have another project that a began last week, a table runner with appliqued and embroidered butterflies on, that needs a bit more embroidery, then backing and binding. I fused Angelina fibres for the applique fabric for the butterflies. I am happy with how they are looking. I now have the next lesson in my quilting course, which is free motion quilting, so I intend to use the exercises on my UFOs, so two birds with one stone, lol. The tutor included a free project with that lesson, too … Well, tomorrow is another day. My aim is to get two UFOs completed by the end of next week

    • Sarah
      May 25, 2020 / 3:45 pm

      Ah I have some of those Really Useful boxes! They’re great aren’t they! I have some smaller ones which hold the offcuts of fabric, and interfacing, and then I have some reallllly large crate-sized ones which hold fabric as well!
      The table runner sounds gorgeous! We have a dining room table but it’s permanently set up with my sewing machine on it… so no room for a table runner lol. I really should check out these online craft courses – though I feel like I’d be heading down a rabbit hole!!

  13. May 25, 2020 / 6:04 pm

    I love this sweater! You do put a huge amount of effort in though and I’m now wondering which of us is normal: me who unravels only if the top is barbie sized and maybe not then, and you who unravels every time you find something you don’t like 😂

    • Sarah
      June 13, 2020 / 5:45 pm

      Ahaaaaa I’m not sure who is normal 😂 I guess we’d need a larger sample size to determine that 😂 I just think that knitting takes SO long (usually), I don’t want to put in ALL that time for something that’s just ‘meh’ at the end 🤷🏻‍♀️

I love reading your comments and thoughts - talk to me!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Fabulous handmade gifts available in my Etsy store!

Caticorn book sleeve
Stars Zip Pouch
Galaxy Cat Book sleeve
Asian Manga bag
Halloween Cat bag
Rainbow Cat book sleeve
Leopard book sleeve
Rainbow gem bag
Pink and metallic gold bag
Glow in the dark constellations bag
Halloween Cat Book Sleeve
Caticorn book sleeve
Stars Zip Pouch
Galaxy Cat Book sleeve
Asian Manga bag
Halloween Cat bag
Rainbow Cat book sleeve
Leopard book sleeve
Rainbow gem bag
Pink and metallic gold bag
Glow in the dark constellations bag
Halloween Cat Book Sleeve
Shop Now